[Issue 101] How much should CEOs be paid?
Another week, another topic to nerd out about in your inbox.
This week I want to revisit the topic of CEO pay. You might recall back in 2018 (Issue #054) when we talked about the Pay Ratio Disclosure Rule, which was being implemented by many companies around that time.
The rule requires companies to disclose the ratio of the median of the annual total compensation of all employees to the CEO's. It was thought that the transparency would help reign in the growing divide.
Earlier this year Bloomberg analyzed pay ratios at the largest public companies in the U.S. and found that not only are CEO pay ratios extraordinarily high, but hundreds of companies pay their median employees less than a living wage.
And sadly, it doesn't appear to be getting better—at least not yet.
According to the latest research:
Nearly 80% of S&P companies paid their CEO 100x their median worker in 2018.
49 of the 500 largest publicly traded companies pay their median worker below the poverty line for a family of 4 (which is still not even a living wage IMO).
At the 50 companies with the widest pay gaps in 2018, the typical employee would have to work at least 1,000 years to earn what their CEO made in just one.
Since it appears that pay disclosures haven't impacted shareholder approval of executive compensation (yet... I'm an optimist after all), the next source of power would be regulation.
The research report I mentioned above included a really comprehensive set of recommendations.
Here are a few I like:
Raise tax rate on firms with wide gaps. Portland, Oregon is the first jurisdiction to pass legislation on this! Any company with a ratio over 100x owe an extra 10% in taxes and companies with more than 250x pay an extra 25%.
Disclosure of executive versus worker raises, which should be tied together don't you think?
Limit tax deductions for executive pay, which I cannot even believe is a thing.
Limit stock buybacks, as it is a driver of inequality. This is also a deeper conversation for a future issue of the newsletter.
Require gender and racial pay gap disclosures, which will help with data to address income inequality.
You can check out the full list here (starting on page 12).
Which ideas resonate with you? What would you add? Hit reply and let me know what you think will make a difference.
Until next week,
P.S. If you work at a publicly traded company and want to see where it falls in this discussion, check out Bloomberg's interactive chart.
Do you enjoy Above the Bottom Line?
The best way to support our success is to join the Patreon community!
A Rare Tech Company Where Women Dominate. This article discusses how ThirdLove, an internet bra retailer based in San Francisco, defies trends in the tech industry by having a staff of 85% females. This jumps to 90% on the data science team. Since their data teams works on AI and algorithms that help shoppers determine the best fit of bra, many male workers are not as interested in working there. // FORTUNE
CVS And Walgreens Pull Heartburn Drug Zantac From Shelves Over FDA Carcinogen Warning. The FDA recently warned the public that popular heartburn drug Zantac possibly contains small amounts of a carcinogen called NDMA, which is used to induce cancer in lab animals. In response, several drug store chains have pulled the product from their shelves, including Walgreens, Walmart, and CVS. // GIZMODO
Uber Reportedly Tells Its Staff Not To Disclose Potential Crimes. According to The Washington Post, Uber’s customer service department is directed to side in favor of the company and driver during a complaint, most of which involve sexual assault. Employees have come forward to reveal that they are not allowed to contact police or advise victims to seek action after complaints of assault from a driver. Furthermore, Uber has a policy of allowing 3 serious complaints of assault against a single driver before taking the driver off the road. // ENGADGET
Get Hired By One Of These 10 Companies If You Want To Be Happy At Work In 2019. This article by Fast Company shows the top ten of Comparably’s Happiest Workers in the U.S. list, which ranks America’s most satisfied employees by compensation, work-life balance, perks/benefits, office culture, and personal feelings towards their own company. Among the top ten are Zoom Video, LinkedIn, Costco, and Microsoft. // FAST COMPANY
Allbirds to Amazon: Don’t Steal Our Design, Steal Our Sustainable Practices. Amazon, which is known for creating cheap knockoffs of well known brands to sell on their marketplace, has recently created a wool-blend sneaker shoe for their in-house brand, which many are saying looks just like Allbirds’ flagship product, the Wool Runner. Allbird’s co-CEO Joey Zwillinger has responded to this by saying he is less upset about the similarities in design and more upset that “Amazon did not go so far as to copy Allbirds’ stringent sustainability practices”, and while he does not want Amazon to copy their team’s designs, he would like for Amazon to copy their sustainability practices. // FAST COMPANY
Johnson & Johnson Settles Ohio Lawsuit To Avoid Federal Trial. Weeks after an Oklahoma judge ordered Johnson & Johnson to pay damages to the state for its part in fueling the opioid epidemic in Oklahoma, two Ohio counties have settled with the healthcare giant to avoid a trial which seeks to hold the company responsible for their part in fueling the epidemic in Ohio. Multiple manufacturers will be on trial in Cleveland for the opioid epidemic later this month. // REUTERS
Bank of America Settles DOL Hiring Bias Probe For $4.2 Million. Bank of America will be paying $4.2 million to settle multiple allegations that they refused to hire women and minorities for different jobs in four states, according to the U.S. Department of Labor. The bank turned away black, Hispanic, and female job applicants for customer service positions in Texas, New Jersey, Florida, and Georgia. // REUTERS
This week's headlines were curated by ABL's intern, Lora, with GIFs from yours truly.
"Jesus Christ himself isn't worth 500 times his median worker pay in companies."
- Abigail Disney
Granddaughter of Roy Disney, co-founder of The Walt Disney Co. (whose CEO is paid 1,424x the median worker)